Reverse engineering or redesign: which do you need

Someone hands you a worn part with no drawing and asks for ten more. Do you copy it, or do you fix what is wrong with it? That is the real difference between reverse engineering and redesign.

Reverse engineering: copy it accurately

You scan the part (or measure it), rebuild it as a CAD model, and the new part matches the old one. It is the right call for obsolete spares, parts that must fit existing equipment, and cases where the original works fine and you just cannot get it any more.

Redesign: change what is wrong

If the part keeps cracking, weighs too much or is expensive to make, copying it just copies the problem. Redesign starts from the job the part has to do and changes shape, material or process to suit. It takes more time up front, and it pays back when the part is made again and again.

Often it is both

A common route is to scan the original so the mating surfaces and holes are right, then change the weak area, such as a thicker wall at the failure point or an added rib. Two practical notes: shiny or transparent surfaces need a light coating before scanning, and internal features a scanner cannot see have to be measured another way.

Send us the part and tell us what went wrong with it. We will say whether a straight copy or a redesign makes more sense.